I love the story of State Sen. Brent Waltz (R-36th) versus his primary opponent, Mike Beeles. Beeles was attempting to get Waltz knocked off the primary ballot due to residency issues (thus making Beele's the GOP nominee by default in a strong GOP district). But he gave a little to much detail, and now Sen. Waltz has a restraining order against Beeles. That one backfired...
In GOP slating, Waltz was unopposed in his slating, as were all of the incumbent legislators. Sitting Judges Ken Johnson, John Hammel, and Gary Miller were not slated, raising a few eyebrows. Teacher Adam Nelson got the nod for House District 86 (vacated by Orentlicher) over attorney Kurt Webber, who got close in his race to unseat Monroe Gray last November.
On the Dem side, they cut some dead weight by not slating Mary Catherine Barton. However, Chiropractor Ken Ackles was slated again for County Coroner, setting up a tough re-election battle. Dems also slate Mary Ann O'Sullivan over City-County Councilor Dane Mahern in District 97 (vacated by Elrod).
Some of these surprises were bin contests between two good candidates, or where the challenger was superior to the incumbent. Others represented races where the party loyalist won out over the better General Election candidate. Our view is that in such a predicament, always go with the better candidate over the favorite son.
Let's put it this way: If Peyton Manning retired, we'd hope the Colts would investigate finding the best quarterback available before elevating Jim Sorgi, even through Sorgi has "put in his time within the organization." Successful party politics is no different.